Democratisation and the Labour Struggle: Trade Union Dynamics in Malaysian Borneo and Indonesian Borneo

Sharifah Nursyahidah Syed Annuar

doi:10.19184/jseahr.v8i2.45220

Authors

Sharifah Nursyahidah Syed Annuar National University of Malaysia, Malaysia

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.19184/jseahr.v8i2.45220

Keywords:

Borneo, Malaysia, Indonesia, trade union, labour movement, democratisation

Abstract

Trade unions are proliferating in Malaysia despite the presence of a semi-authoritarian climate. Comparatively, Indonesia is observing a decline in trade unions and respective membership despite a developing democracy. The present study aims to assess the trade unions in Malaysian and Indonesian Borneo that are rarely given attention. The literature reveals that the national culture significantly influences trade unions in both regions. For instance, the trade unions in Malaysian Borneo are highly distinctive compared to those of Peninsular Malaysia. Subsequently, national culture, including individualism and collectivism, uncertainty avoidance, power distance, and masculinity versus femininity, affect adherence to the national trend. Moreover, internal and external factors, such as union awareness, the commando spirit, cooperative or confrontational attitudes, employment laws, and opinion differences, could impact trade unions and democracy. Accordingly, this study conducts case studies in both regions on three main economic sectors with high similarities, namely oil and gas, timber, and palm oil, to determine the underlying factors. Although Malaysian and Indonesian Borneo demonstrated significant differences in the observance of national trends, similar democracy challenges, especially marginalisation and disempowerment of workers and trade unions, were observed.

Keywords: Borneo, Malaysia, Indonesia, Trade Union, Labour Movement, Democratisation

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Acemoglu, Daron & James Robinson, Economic Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy

(Cambridge University Press, 2006).

Amalia, Ezka, “Sustaining Transnational Activism between Indonesia and Hong Kong”

(2020) 29:1 Asian Pac Migr J 12–29.

Aminuddin, Maimunah, “Employment Relations in Malaysia: Past, Present and Future”

(2009) 11:1 N Z J Asian Stud 304–317.

Arifin, Syarif, “Omnibus Law Cipta Kerja: Sesajen bagi Pemodal [Omnibus Law on Job Creation: Offerings for investors]” Sedane (12 March 2020), online:

<http://majalahsedane.org/omnibus-law-cipta-kerja-sesajen-bagi-pemodal/>.

Aspinall, Edward & Greg Fealy, “Introduction: Soeharto’s New Order and its Legacy” in Edward Aspinall & Greg Fealy, eds, Soeharto’s New Order Its Leg Essays Honour Harold Crouch (ANU Press, 2010).

Aspinall, Edward et al, “Elites, Masses, and Democratic Decline in Indonesia” (2020) 27:4

Democratization 505–526.

Baccaro, Lucio, Chiara Benassi & Guglielmo Meardi, “Theoretical and empirical links between trade unions and democracy” (2019) 40:1 Econ Ind Democr 3–19.

Bamber, Greg J, Marjorie A Jerrard & Paul F Clark, “How do trade unions manage themselves? A study of Australian unions’ administrative practices” (2022) 64:5 J Ind Relat 623–644.

Black, Boyd, “Comparative Industrial Relations Theory: The Role of National Culture”

(2005) 16:7 Int J Hum Resour Manag 1137–1158.

———, “National Culture and Industrial Relations and Pay Structures” (2001) 15:2

LABOUR Rev Labour Econ Ind Relat 257–277.

Bowen, John, “On the Political Construction of Tradition: Gotong Royong in Indonesia”

(1986) 45:3 J Asian Stud 545–561.

Brookes, Marissa, “Explaining Employer Responses to Transnational Labor Activism: Indonesia and Cambodia Compared” (2018) 51:6 Comp Polit Stud 699–729.

Cameron, Lisa, Diana Contreras Suarez & William Rowell, “Female Labour Force Participation in Indonesia: Why Has it Stalled?” (2018) Bull Indones Econ Stud 1– 40.

Caraway, Teri L, Michele Ford & Hari Nugroho, “Translating membership into power at the ballot box? Trade union candidates and worker voting patterns in Indonesia’s national elections” (2015) 22:7 Democratization 1296–1316.

CNN Indonesia, “Minister: Number of Trade Unions Drop Significantly”, CNN Indones

(29 March 2018), online:

<https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20180328143824-20- 286542/menaker- jumlah-serikat-pekerja-menurun-signifikan>.

Crinis, Vicki & Balakrishnan Parasuraman, “Employment Relations and the State in Malaysia” (2016) 58:2 J Ind Relat 215–228.

Croucher, Richard & Lillian Miles, “Ethnicity, Popular Democratic Movements and Labour in Malaysia” (2018) 39:2 Econ Ind Democr 294–311.

Daily Express, “SLO Changes: Employers Lament Non-Consultation”, Dly Express (17 February 2019), online:

<http://www.dailyexpress.com.my/news.cfm?NewsID=131348>.

Department of Statistics Malaysia, Keluaran Dalam Negeri Kasar Mengikut Negeri 2016 [Gross Domestic Product by State 2016], by Department of Statistics Malaysia (Department of Statistics Malaysia, 2017).

———, Pocket Stats Q1 2020, by Department of Statistics Malaysia (Department of Statistics Malaysia, 2020).

Department of Trade Union Affairs Malaysia, Trade Unions Statistics in Malaysia 2014- 2018 (Department of Trade Union Affairs Malaysia).

Eden, Dzulzalani & Mohamad Suhaidi Salleh et al, eds, “Introduction: Trade Unions and Industrial Relations Systems” in Study Trade Union Eff Malays (Cyberjaya: Institute of Labour Market Information and Analysis, 2017).

Elischer, Sebastian, “Trade union mobilisation and democratic institutionalisation in the Republic of Niger” (2019) 46:160 Rev Afr Polit Econ 204–222.

Ford, Michele, “Learning by Doing: Trade Unions and Electoral Politics in Batam,

Indonesia, 2004-2009” (2014) 22:3 South East Asia Res 341–357.

———, “The Global Union Federations and Temporary Labour Migration in Malaysia”

(2013) 55:2 J Ind Relat 260–276.

Frege, Carola M, John Kelly & Patrick G McGovern, “Richard Hyman: Marxism, Trade Unionism and Comparative Employment Relations” (2011) 49:2 209–230.

Gillan, Michael, “Re-Making Labour in India: State Policy, Corporate Power and Labour Movement Mobilisation” in Kenneth Nielsen & Alf Nilsen, eds, Soc Mov State India Deep Democr (Palgrave Macmillan, 2016).

Gilley, Bruce, “Democratic Enclaves in Authoritarian Regimes” (2010) 17:3 389-415.” (2010) 17:3 Democratization 389–415.

Gomez, Edmund & Jomo KS, Malaysia’s Political Economy: Politics, Patronage and Profits

(Cambridge University Press, 1997).

Guest, Greg, Arwen Bunce & Laura Johnson, “How Many Interviews Are Enough?: An Experiment with Data Saturation and Variability” (2006) 18:1 Field Methods 59–82.

Gumbrell-McCormick, Rebecca & Richard Hyman, “Democracy in trade unions, democracy through trade unions?” (2018) Econ Ind Democr 1–20.

Habibi, Muhtar & Benny Hari Juliawan, “Creating Surplus Labour: Neo- Liberal Transformations and the Development of Relative Surplus Population in Indonesia” 48:4 J Contemp Asia 649–670.

Hadiz, Vedi, “Globalization, Labour and the State: The Case of Indonesia” (2000) 6:3 Asia

Pac Bus Rev 239–259.

Hoey, Brian, “Nationalism in Indonesia: Building Imagined and Intentional

Communities through Transmigration” (2003) 42:2 Ethnology 109–126.

Hofstede Insights, “Country Comparison”, (16 October 2023), online:

<https://www.hofstede-insights.com/country-comparison/saudi-arabia,the- usa/#:~:text=Saudi%20Arabia%2C%20with%20a%20score,considered%20a%20slig htly%20collectivistic%20society>.

Hofstede, Geert, “Dimensionalizing Cultures: The Hofstede Model in Context” (2011) 2:1

Online Read Psychol Cult 1–26.

Hung, Ying-Cheng, Tzu-Cheng Su & Kuo-Ren Lou, “Impact of Organizational Culture on Individual Work Performance with National Culture of Cross-Strait Enterprises as a Moderator” (2022) 14:11 Sustainability 6897.

Hwa, Ng, “A Labour Agenda for Malaysia”, New Mandala (20 January 2023), online:

<https://www.newmandala.org/a-labour-agenda-for-malaysia/>.

Hyman, Richard, “The state in industrial relations” in P Blyton et al, eds, SAGE Handb Ind Relat (SAGE Publications, 2008).

Indrasari Tjandraningsih, “State-Sponsored Precarious Work in Indonesia” (2013) 57:4

Am Behav Sci 403–419.

Jangli, Muzdalifah & Fazli Abd Hamid, “Densiti, Cakupan dan Pengiktirafan Kesatuan Sekerja: Analisis Kajian Lepas [Union Density, Coverage and Recognition: A Previous Study Analysis]” (2018) 28 MANU J Pus Penataran Ilmu Bhs 183–197.

Jayani, Dwi Hadya, “Minat Pekerja Ikut Serikat Berkurang [Workers’ Interest in

Joining the Union Decreases]”, (17 October 2019), online: Databoks

<https://databoks.katadata.co.id/datapublish/2019/10/17/kepersertaan-serikat- pekerja-menurun>.

John Crossan et al, “Colours of Democracy: Trade Union Banners and the Contested Articulations of Democratic Spatial Practices” (2022) 48:1 Trans Inst Br Geogr 1– 16.

Kamaruddin, Nurliana & Roy Rogers, “Malaysia’s Democratic and Political Transformation” (2020) 47:2 Asian Aff Am Rev 126–148.

Kaur, Amarjit, Wage Labour in Southeast Asia Since 1840: Globalisation, the International Division of Labour and Labour Transformation (Palgrave Macmillan, 2004).

Keane, Lauren, Alexander Pacek & Benjamin Radcliff, “Organized Labor, Democracy,

and Life Satisfaction: A Cross-National Analysis” (2012) 37:3 Labor Stud J 253–270.

Kelly, Caroline & John Kelly, “Who Gets Involved in Collective Action? Social Psychological Determinants of Individual Participation in Trade Unions” (1994) 47:1 Hum Relat 63–88.

Kollmeyer, Christopher, “Post-Industrial Capitalism and Trade Union Decline in Affluent

Democracies” (2021) 62:6 Int J Comp Sociol 466–487.

Krippendorff, Klaus, Content Analysis: An Introduction to its Methodology (SAGE Publications, 2013).

Kumar, Naresh, Miguel Martínez Lucio & Raduan Che Rose, “Workplace industrial relations in a developing environment : barriers to renewal within unions in Malaysia” (2013) 51:1 Asia Pac J Hum Resour 22–44.

Loker Kaltim, “Daftar Upah Minimum Kota/Kabupaten (UMK) Provinsi Kalimantan Timur Tahun 2019 [List of District/City Minimum Wage (UMK) of East Kalimantan Province 2019]”, (2018), online: Loker Kaltim

<https://www.lokerkaltim.net/2018/12/daftar-upah-minimum-kota-kabupaten-umk- provinsi-kalimantan-timur-tahun-2019.html>.

Malaysiakini, “Rundingan Tergendala, 80 Pekerja Syarikat Elektronik Berpiket [Stalled Negotiations, 80 Electronics Company Workers Picketed]”, Malaysiakini (14 February 2020), online: <https://www.malaysiakini.com/news/510902>.

Maleki, Ammar & Frank Hendriks, “The Relation between Cultural Values and Models

of Democracy: A Cross-National Study” (2015) 22:6 Democratization 981–1010.

Merriam, Sharran, Case Study Research in Education: A Qualitative Approach (Jossey- Bass, 1988).

Miles, Lilian et al, “Advocacy for women migrant workers in Malaysia through an intersectionality lens” (2019) 61:5 J Ind Relat 682–703.

Miles, Lillian & Richard Croucher, “Gramsci, Counter-Hegemony and Labour Union-Civil

Society Organisation Coalitions in Malaysia” (2013) 43:3 J Contemp Asia 413–427.

Mohamed, Suhaila, Faridahwati Mohd Shamsudin & Husna Johari, “Union Organisation and Effectiveness: An Empirical Study on In-house Union in Malaysia” (2010) 78:1 Akad J Southeast Asia Soc Sci Humanit 89–94.

Morris, Alan, A Practical Introduction to In-Depth Interviewing (SAGE Publications, 2015).

Mustofa, Muhammad, “Labour Rights and Law Enforcement: The Role of the Indonesian National Police in Maintaining Order during Industrial Disputes” (2008) 9 Labour Manag Dev 82–90.

Nor, Che Supian Mohamad et al, “Trade Unions: Relevant Out of Irrelevant? A Study on Generation’s Perception in Malaysia” (2018) 8:3 Int J Hum Resour Stud 3852–3852.

Pillay, Somma & Nirmala Dorasamy, “Linking Cultural Dimensions with the Nature of Corruption: An Institutional Theory Perspective” (2010) 10:3 Int J Cross Cult Manag 363–378.

Prakoso, Jaffry Prabu, “Gubernur Kaltim: Kita Berprasangka Baik Omnibus Law Bermanfaat [Kaltim Governor: We Opined Omnibus Law is Beneficial]”, (6 March 2020), online: Bisnis

<https://kalimantan.bisnis.com/read/20200306/408/1210072/gubernur-kaltim-kita- berprasangka-baik-omnibus-law-bermanfaat>.

Pratomo, Nurhadi, “Serikat Pekerja: Kepesertaan Terus Turun [Trade Unions: Membership Continue to Decline]”, (2 May 2017), online: Bisnis

<http://jakarta.bisnis.com/read/20170502/448/649648/serikat-pekerja-kepesertaan- terus-turun>.

Rahman, Dzulfiqar Fathur, “Hanya 12% Pekerja yang Tergabung dalam Serikat Pekerja pada 2021 [Only 12% of Workers are Unionized in 2021]”, (11 April 2022), online: Databoks <https://databoks.katadata.co.id/datapublish/2022/04/11/hanya- 12-pekerja-yang-tergabung-dalam-serikat-pekerja-pada-2021>.

Razak, Siti Suraya Abd & Nik Ahmad Kamal Nik Mahmod, “Ratification of International Labour Convention and the Reformation of Trade Union Recognition Process in Malaysia” 29:1 Pertanika J Soc Sci Humanit 193–206.

Robison, Richard & Vedi Hadiz, Reorganising Power in Indonesia: The Politics of Oligarchy in an Age of Markets (Routledge Curzon, 2004).

Ronald, Inglehart, Miguel Basatez & Alejandro Moreno, Human Beliefs and Values: A Cross-Cultural Sourcebook based on the 1999-2002 Value Surveys (Siglo XXI, 2004).

Rowley, Chris & Mhinder Bhopal, “The Role of Ethnicity in Employee Relations: The Case of Malaysia” (2005) 43:3 Asia Pac J Hum Resour 308–331.

Rupidara, Neil & Peter McGraw, “Institutional Change, Continuity and Decoupling in

the Indonesian Industrial Relations System” (2010) 52:5 J Ind Relat 613–630.

Saunders, Benjamin et al, “Saturation in qualitative research: exploring its conceptualization and operationalization” (2018) 52:4 Qual Quant 1893–1907.

Sedane, “Mengumpan Buruh Sebagai Tumbal Pandemi [Labour as the Victim of Pandemic]” Sedane (13 May 2020), online: <https://majalahsedane.org/mengumpan- buruh-sebagai-tumbal-pandemi/>.

Sender, Anna, Alexandra Arnold & Bruno Staffelbach, “Job security as a threatened resource : reactions to job insecurity in culturally distinct regions” (2016) 28:17 Int J Hum Resour Manag.

Shahiri, Hazrul, Zulkifly Osman & Kihong Park, “Union Relevance in the Malaysian Labour Market” 30:2 Asian-Pac Econ Lit 45–56.

Siregar, Boyke P, “72 Perusahaan Jadi Objek Vital Industri [72 Companies Become

Industrial Vital Object]”, War Ekon (7 February 2018), online:

<https://www.wartaekonomi.co.id/read170045/72-perusahaan-jadi-objek-vital- industri>.

Statistics Indonesia Balikpapan, Kota Balikpapan dalam Angka 2018 [Balikpapan in Number 2018, by Statistics Indonesia Balikpapan (BPS Kota Balikpapan, 2018).

Supreme Court of the Republic of Indonesia, Statistik Perkara [Case Statistics], by Supreme Court of the Republic of Indonesia (Supreme Court of the Republic of Indonesia, 2020).

Taejoon, Ahn, “The Labour Movement and Party Politics in Malaysia” (2006) 9:1 Int Area

Stud Rev 35–58.

Tjandra, Surya, Trade Union Movement and Democracy in Indonesia: 2010, 2014, and Beyond, by Surya Tjandra (Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung, 2017).

Todd, Patricia & D Peetz, “Malaysian Industrial Relations at Century’s Turn: Vision 2020 or a Spectre of the Past?” (2001) 12:8 Int J Hum Resour Manag 1365–1382.

Utusan Borneo, “MTUC Sarawak Sokong Sepenuhnya Pindaan Akta Perhubungan Perusahaan [MTUC Sarawak Fully Supports the Amendment of the Industrial Relations Act]”, (11 December 2019), online: Utusan Borneo

<https://www.utusanborneo.com.my/2019/12/11/mtuc-sarawak-sokong-sepenuhnya- pindaan-akta-perhubungan-perusahaan>.

Wad, Peter, “Revitalizing the Malaysian Trade Union Movement: The Case of the Electronics Industry” (2012) 54:4 J Ind Relat 494–509.

Wallace, Michael, Todd E Vachon & Allen Hyde, “Two roads diverged: Legal context and changing levels of private and public sector union density in the US states, 1984– 2019” (2021) 43:4 Econ Ind Democr 1539–1563.

Ward, Kristy & Vichhra Mouyly, “Employment Relations and Political Transition

in Cambodia” (2016) 58:2 J Ind Relat 258–272.

Wilson, Ian, Politik Jatah Preman: Ormas dan Kuasa Jalanan di Indonesia Pasca Orde Baru [The Politics of Protection Rackets in Post-New Order Indonesia: Coercive Capital, Authority and Street Politics] (Marjin Kiri, 2018).

Wiratraman, R Herlambang Perdana, “Disciplining Post Suharto-Labour Law Reform” in Jafar Suryomenggolo, ed, Work Act Reformasi 1998 New Phase Indones Unions (Asia Monitor Resource Centre, 2014).

Wu, Ming-Yi, Maureen Taylor & Mong-Ju Chen, “Exploring Societal and Cultural Influences on Taiwanese Public Relations” (2001) 27:3 Public Relat Rev 317–336.

Yin, Robert, Case Study Research: Design and Methods (SAGE Publications, 2013).

Young, Sokphea, “Organization without Revolution: The Labour Movement and the Failure of Democratization in Cambodia” (2021) 43:2 Contemp Southeast Asia 345– 369.